Investing 101

Warning Signs of a Bad Commercial Real Estate Deal


The TermSheet Team


Feb 13, 2024

The bustling commercial real estate market harbors its share of pitfalls, and navigating through them is as much an art as it is a science. For the discerning and vigilant investor, being able to recognize a potentially bad CRE deal is just as important as identifying a lucrative one. Here we will dive deeper into five critical warning signs that could spell trouble for your next deal, so you know when to steer clear of a potentially bad investment. 

Overinflated Property Valuations

Real estate is an industry notorious for its fluctuating values, often inflating to dizzying heights or plummeting to unexpected lows. The specter of overinflated valuations can cast a particularly long shadow over a CRE deal, leading to a host of complications that could affect the asset's long-term profitability.

The Risks of Overinflated Valuations
When the perceived market value of a property is artificially increased, several risks emerge. Financing a CRE deal based on a property that is overvalued can lead to a scenario where the asset does not generate sufficient income to service its debt. Moreover, overvaluation can skew your estimated returns, leading to a miscalculation of the investment's actual worth.

Identifying Overinflated Valuations
A critical eye towards the appraisal report or a projected P&L statement is necessary to spot discrepancies. Look for any unusual leaps in the property's valuation history and unlikely assumptions regarding vacancy or costs associated with ownership. Cross-reference with comparable sales & market data to come to your own determination of value.

Poor Location

One of the indisputable axioms of real estate is that it's all about "location, location, location." The geographical anchor of a property is a significant determinant of its viability and desirability.

The Impact of Location
A property's location dictates its accessibility, visibility, and potential customer base, especially in the retail and service sectors. Proximity to amenities, the demographic profile of the neighborhood, and local market trends can profoundly influence the performance of CRE investments.

Red Flags in Location Considerations
Signs of a poor location may include a high degree of obsolescence in the neighborhood, stagnant or declining population growth, and an absence of new infrastructure or amenity development. Alternatively, a market with a growing number of competing properties can signal impending challenges in tenant acquisition or retention.

High Vacancy Rates

Vacancy rates are the heartbeat of CRE; they indicate the health of a property's income-generating machinery. Beyond mere numbers, high vacancy rates can be symptomatic of underlying issues that require careful diagnosis.

The Significance of Vacancy Rates
High rates of unoccupied space imply an inability of the property to draw and retain tenants. This translates to decreased cash flow, potentially increased operational costs due to a lack of economies of scale, and, ultimately, a less attractive investment for potential buyers if you decide to sell.

Identifying High Vacancy Rates
A vacancy rate significantly above the market average, persistent difficulty in filling space, or a high turnover of tenants are clear indicators that a deeper investigation into the property's appeal and management practices is warranted. When conducting initial diligence on a property, be sure to double check all of the assumptions regarding occupancy, as they are often inaccurate and have a direct impact on the capitalization rate.

Unfavorable Lease Terms

The fine print of lease agreements can steer delicate CRE deals off course, subtly undermining their financial merits over time. These terms can range from rental rates and escalation clauses to tenant improvement allowances and responsibility for utilities, maintenance and taxes.

The Importance of Lease Agreement Review
Lease agreements are the contractual bedrock of commercial tenancy. All value in CRE flows from the lease agreement. They outline the obligations and expectations of both landlord and tenant, impacting the asset’s cash flow and potential resale value. As such, a comprehensive review of these documents is non-negotiable.

Warning Signs of Unfavorable Lease Terms
Look out for lease concessions that are significantly below market standards, unusually long or short lease terms relative to the market, and leases that lack clauses to protect the landlord's interests, such as robust default provisions.

Lack of Due Diligence

The diligence in due diligence is not to be overlooked in CRE investing. A lack thereof can open the floodgates to unforeseen liabilities, concealed challenges, and missed opportunities.

The Role of Due Diligence
Due diligence is the process of investigation, verification, and validation of every aspect of a CRE investment. It encompasses legal, financial, operational, and market assessments to ensure all relevant information is unearthed before finalizing the deal.

Indicators of Insufficient Due Diligence
An absence of comprehensive property inspections, cursory financial analysis, and reliance on outdated or incomplete data are signs of a due diligence process that is not up to par. In such cases, assuming and mitigating risks are compromised, leaving the investment vulnerable. As an investor, you need to be able to conduct your own analysis or that of a trusted partner to be certain of these factors, not just rely on the representation of the seller.


The ability to spot a problematic commercial real estate deal is a skill that sharpens with experience, industry knowledge, and a cautious approach. By heeding the warning signs of overinflated valuations, poor location, high vacancy rates, unfavorable lease terms, and a lack of due diligence, investors can avoid potentially disastrous real estate transactions and safeguard their portfolios.

Boost your productivity now

Schedule a personalized demo today to see how TermSheet can help you to get more value out of real estate datasets.

Get Started →

Boost Your Productivity Now

Schedule a personalized demo today to see how TermSheet can help you to get more value out of real estate datasets

Get Started →

© 2024, TermSheet, LLC. All All rights reserved.

© 2024, TermSheet, LLC. All All rights reserved.

© 2024, TermSheet, LLC. All All rights reserved.